Why Performance Indicators Fail
In many institutions, long meetings are held to approve performance indicators. Elegant spreadsheets are designed for them, and monthly reports arrive on schedule. Then the year passes, and not a single decision has changed because of them.
The problem is not the absence of indicators. It is their presence without meaning.
First: we measure what is easy to measure, not what should be measured. The number of completed transactions is an easy figure, but it does not tell us whether the client left satisfied, or how many times they returned to complete the same paperwork. A good indicator answers a question that matters to management, not one that is convenient for staff to answer.
Second: the indicator without an owner. When an indicator is everyone's responsibility, it is in truth no one's. Every number needs a person who is accountable for it and who has the authority to improve it.
Third: the numbers arrive late. A report that lands after the quarter has closed is fit only for the archive. An indicator's value lies in its timing, not in its accuracy alone.
Fourth: no one asks "and then what?" An indicator that is not tied to a decision in advance — if it falls, we do this; if it rises, we do that — becomes a number for display, not for management.
The rule I have learned over the years: a few indicators, each with an owner, a decision attached to it, and an information system that feeds it on time. Five living indicators are worth more than fifty on paper.
Indicators are not instruments of control; they are instruments of thought. When an institution understands that, the numbers begin to speak.
